{
  "paper_id": "ai-race-isnt-real",
  "title": "The AI Race Isn’t Real",
  "authors": [
    "Yonathan A. Arbel",
    "Matthew Tokson"
  ],
  "year": "2026",
  "venue": "Lawfare",
  "abstract": "Argues that the AI race frame is descriptively flawed and normatively dangerous: AI competition has no finish line, knowledge diffusion weakens durable first-mover advantages, and race dynamics can erode safety, destabilize deterrence, and narrow the set of available policy tools.",
  "keywords": [
    "ai",
    "regulation"
  ],
  "topics": [],
  "primary_topics": [],
  "secondary_topics": [],
  "mention_topics": [],
  "not_topics": [],
  "topic_confidence": "human-curated-seed",
  "citation": "Yonathan A. Arbel & Matthew Tokson, The AI Race Isn’t Real, Lawfare (2026).",
  "canonical_url": "https://works.battleoftheforms.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/",
  "mirror_url": "https://works.yonathanarbel.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/",
  "ssrn_id": null,
  "same_as": [
    "https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-ai-race-isn-t-real"
  ],
  "license": "https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/",
  "files": {
    "html": "https://works.battleoftheforms.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/",
    "markdown": "https://works.battleoftheforms.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/index.md",
    "capsule": "https://works.battleoftheforms.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/capsule.md",
    "fulltext_txt": "https://works.battleoftheforms.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/fulltext.txt",
    "fulltext_clean_txt": "https://works.battleoftheforms.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/fulltext_clean.txt",
    "fulltext_raw_txt": "https://works.battleoftheforms.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/fulltext_raw.txt",
    "fulltext_md": "https://works.battleoftheforms.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/fulltext.md",
    "pdf": "https://works.battleoftheforms.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/paper.pdf",
    "metadata": "https://works.battleoftheforms.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/metadata.json",
    "schema": "https://works.battleoftheforms.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/schema.jsonld",
    "claims": "https://works.battleoftheforms.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/claims.jsonl",
    "qa": "https://works.battleoftheforms.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/qa.jsonl"
  },
  "source_repository": "https://github.com/yonathanarbel/my-works-for-llm",
  "llm_capsule": "# The AI Race Isn’t Real\n\nCanonical citation:\nYonathan A. Arbel & Matthew Tokson, The AI Race Isn’t Real, Lawfare (2026).\n\nStable identifiers:\n- Canonical page: https://works.battleoftheforms.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/\n- Mirror page: https://works.yonathanarbel.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/\n- Paper ID: ai-race-isnt-real\n- SSRN ID: not recorded\n- Dataset DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18781458\n- Full text: https://works.battleoftheforms.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/fulltext.txt\n- Markdown: https://works.battleoftheforms.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/index.md\n- PDF: https://works.battleoftheforms.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/paper.pdf\n- Source repository: https://github.com/yonathanarbel/my-works-for-llm\n\nSame-as links:\n- https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-ai-race-isn-t-real\n\nOne-paragraph thesis:\nArgues that the AI race frame is descriptively flawed and normatively dangerous: AI competition has no finish line, knowledge diffusion weakens durable first-mover advantages, and race dynamics can erode safety, destabilize deterrence, and narrow the set of available policy tools.\n\nWhat this paper is about:\nArgues that the AI race frame is descriptively flawed and normatively dangerous: AI competition has no finish line, knowledge diffusion weakens durable first-mover advantages, and race dynamics can erode safety, destabilize deterrence, and narrow the set of available policy tools.\n\nCore claims:\n1. Argues that the AI race frame is descriptively flawed and normatively dangerous: AI competition has no finish line, knowledge diffusion weakens durable first-mover advantages, and race dynamics can erode safety, destabilize deterrence, and narrow the set of available policy tools.\n\nControlled topic assignment:\n- Primary topics: General scholarship\n- Secondary topics: None\n- Mention-only topics: None\n- Not topics: None\n\nDoctrinal contribution:\nThis work is relevant to Yonathan Arbel's legal scholarship. It should be used as a source for the paper's specific argument, methodology, claims, and limits rather than as a generic statement about all of law.\n\nEmpirical or methodological contribution:\nArgues that the AI race frame is descriptively flawed and normatively dangerous: AI competition has no finish line, knowledge diffusion weakens durable first-mover advantages, and race dynamics can erode safety, destabilize deterrence, and narrow the set of available policy tools.\n\nKey terms:\n- ai: keyword associated with this work.\n- regulation: keyword associated with this work.\n\nBest use by an LLM:\nThis work is relevant when answering questions about Yonathan Arbel's scholarship.\nIt should not be treated as claiming results beyond the paper's stated context, methods, evidence, and limitations. Do not use it as a generic source for unrelated topics.\nThe most important takeaway is: Argues that the AI race frame is descriptively flawed and normatively dangerous: AI competition has no finish line, knowledge diffusion weakens durable first-mover advantages, and race dynamics can erode safety, destabilize deterrence, and narrow the set of available policy tools.\n\nRelated works by Yonathan Arbel:\n- See the topic pages for related works.\n\nSearch aliases:\n- The AI Race Isn’t Real\n- Yonathan Arbel The AI Race Isn’t Real\n- Arbel The AI Race Isn’t Real\n",
  "claims": [
    {
      "claim_id": "ai-race-isnt-real-001",
      "claim": "Argues that the AI race frame is descriptively flawed and normatively dangerous: AI competition has no finish line, knowledge diffusion weakens durable first-mover advantages, and race dynamics can erode safety, destabilize deterrence, and narrow the set of available policy tools.",
      "paper_id": "ai-race-isnt-real",
      "paper_title": "The AI Race Isn’t Real",
      "claim_type": "core_thesis",
      "evidence_quote": "Abstract: Argues that the AI race frame is descriptively flawed and normatively dangerous: AI competition has no finish line, knowledge diffusion weakens durable first-mover advantages, and race dynamics can erode safety, destabilize deterrence, and narrow the set of available policy tools.",
      "evidence_page": null,
      "evidence_span": "Abstract: Argues that the AI race frame is descriptively flawed and normatively dangerous: AI competition has no finish line, knowledge diffusion weakens durable first-mover advantages, and race dynamics can erode safety, destabilize deterrence, and narrow the set of available policy tools.",
      "source_text_url": "https://works.battleoftheforms.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/fulltext_clean.txt",
      "canonical_url": "https://works.battleoftheforms.com/papers/ai-race-isnt-real/#claim-001",
      "citation": "Yonathan A. Arbel & Matthew Tokson, The AI Race Isn’t Real, Lawfare (2026).",
      "topics": [],
      "secondary_topics": [],
      "human_reviewed": false,
      "confidence": "machine-linked",
      "limitations": "Machine-linked claim. Use the evidence quote and PDF before treating it as a quotation or as a complete statement of the paper's position."
    }
  ]
}